“It is on us–those of us who get 15 likes and those of us who get 15,000–to be conscientious about how and where we share information on the web about wild places.” Abbie Barronien
A few days ago, friends and I skied the Tower/Chittenden Loop in Yellowstone National Park. It was a lovely day, cloudy with flurries but not too cold. The day before, I had skied the Snow Pass/Bunsen Loop just outside of Mammoth Hot Springs in the Park. Both trails are easily accessible from the year-round roads in the Park, and maps are available in the Mammoth Ski Den.
I write about these places and don’t hesitate to state where they are and how to get there. I’m willing to share my experiences and encourage others to enjoy these trails.
But, I’m less willing to give the exact location at any point in time for the wolves I observe. Or the otters. Or the coyotes. I am less willing to share the exact location of some of my off-trail hikes. I am less willing to share the location of some special but fragile areas. Last autumn, my stomach tightened as I thought about how I should word my posts on Facebook as we traveled and hiked new places.
And I wondered about that tightness. Why shouldn’t I share exact locations and directions? What is the difference between sharing a well-publicized trail in a national park vs an off-trail or more obscure fragile area in other public lands?
So, I’ve considered. And lo and behold—a message in my Inbox directed me to a few sites that address this concern.
Abbie Barronien in The Adventure Journal has a brilliant post on this topic. She puts into words many of my concerns about publicizing exact locations of sensitive areas, and gives suggestions as to how much information to share and on what sites it might be appropriate. It is not selfish. I am not elitist. But I am worried about our over-populated species ‘loving it to death’. Most sensitive areas that are not in a national park (and even many that are) just do not have the oversight protections necessary. It is too easy to show up and trample fragile plants through ignorance or even worse, to purposely deface a natural feature and get away with it.
Another site goes further and calls for an eighth Leave No Trace principle. At present there are seven LNT (Leave No Trace) principles:
- Plan ahead and prepare.
- Travel and camp on durable surfaces.
- Dispose of waste properly.
- Leave what you find.
- Minimize campfire impacts (be careful with fire).
- Respect wildlife.
- Be considerate of other visitors.
These are all important principles, and some think that an eighth principle could be incorporated into one of these. But I believe, with the changes in social media since LNT was established years ago, that there needs to be a principle addressing how we post and what we post on social media. The Hikers for an Eighth Leave No Trace Principle give a few examples of possible wording:
“Be mindful when posting on social media and consider the potential impacts that rapidly increased use can have on wild places”
“Use discretion when posting on social media and consider the potential impacts of creating a ‘buzz’ about specific destinations”
There are no easy solutions. We balance on a fine razor’s edge with wild lands. On the one hand we want all to experience and to fall in love with wild lands, to have a transcendent experience and return home to protect what they love. But we don’t want the landscape over-run and destroyed so that visitors feel a closer connection to Disneyland than to the ‘real world’.
If we really want to travel the trails less traveled, then we should be willing to pay for the adventure. We pay by doing research: buying books, researching photos on line, communicating and asking questions. But even better: stumbling upon a unique place all on our own. It is so much more powerful that way.
An eighth Leave No Trace principle would allow us to be more circumspect in our postings and have it accepted by others. It would give permission to be more thoughtful in how we post what we post. And it would bring more awareness to us all of the importance of our words.
These principles are not rules, but values. As a nation, we hold the value of wild public lands dear. As times change, our values change—it is time to add a social media value to Leave No Trace.
The morning after Christmas, we drove through the Lamar Valley. We were alone on the road, the weather snowy and cold. One of our group noticed ravens in a tree. We’d learned that ravens can be an indicator of predators in the area. Immediately after noticing the ravens, another member pointed out an elk on a cliff, her back to the edge, facing upslope. Just above her we spotted the Lamar Canyon pack—three black wolves who were obviously going after the elk. We found a pull-out, pulled over and silently got out our spotting scopes. The wolves began to move off at the sound of our vehicle but they stayed in the area and made a kill after sunset that night. While we’d seen wolves each day, this was the memory we’ll take with us… it was our own sighting. We paid our dues of getting up early, deciding the direction to travel, and closely scanning the terrain. This is what the eighth LNT principle is about—and it makes the experience powerful enough that it can change lives. It changed my life.
So keep going to wild places. Keep exploring. Get out there and hike and ski and wander and take photos and appreciate silence. Love our lands, love your time on our lands. And be mindful of how you share your adventures.
“Love is a powerful tool, and maybe, just maybe, before the last little town is corrupted and the last of the unroaded and undeveloped wildness is given over to dreams of profit, maybe it will be love, finally, love for the land for its own sake and for what it holds of beauty and joy and spiritual redemption that will make [wilderness] not a battlefield but a revelation.” – T. H. Watkins